Skip to main content

Mother Tongue

While English is spoken as a second language more than as a native language, non-native speakers are often stereotyped or assumed to be, unintelligible or incoherent. As shown in Amy Tan's "Mother Tongue", her mother often gets worse service by doctors, department stores, restaurants, stockbrokers, in comparison to Tan. During her teenage years, Tan often had to call places for her mother, as shown in her interaction with the stockbroker, who may have decided to try and cheat her mother out of her money simply because he may have believed that she wouldn't be able to get her complaints through to his boss (due to her English skill level). Even she (when she was younger) had a negative perception about what her mother had to say, due to her mother's "limited" English. The text provides a perspective of how people with observable 'non-nativeness' (in terms of speaking English), can have very different experiences in day to day life, compared to native speakers. Personally, I believe that there is also a slight racist or xenophobic factor to this as well, as the way one speaks English is one of the ways others can tell where a person is from. And once a person's origin is known, it provides all sorts of stereotypes and preconceptions about the person. For example, if I, as a Norwegian, have a Norwegian accent, then others, who know that accent, may form their own preconceptions about me and my personality despite not knowing who I am (e.g. "That guy must be rolling in the oil money!" or "I bet this guy really likes salmon"). Now while the stereotypes I listed for myself (I'm just using an example, I have no idea if those are actual stereotypes) may be pretty harmless, for other groups of people they can be quite harmful. Groups that are picked on a lot, may be 'outed' by their accent and/or the way they speak, for example. However, in the end, I believe that when people are treated differently because of their way of speaking English, it is more to do with their perceived 'lack of intelligence' (even though one's English skill level has nothing to do with intelligence, it will almost certainly affect other people's perception of your intelligence, if you are in a majority English speaking country/area), rather than overt racism. In my opinion (which I'm sure most of the class would agree), treating a non-native English speaker that is not as proficient at English as the native speakers; as being 'unintelligent' or something similar, is something that should be avoided, and done more to discourage, as it is not a good thing to have worse experience than others simply because you do not know a particular language. While this blog post focused on English, this message, I believe, can be applied to any other language.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Print Advertisement: Nivea Moisturizer

To start off, here's some basic information about the advert. Its target audience is young women, as the main focus of the advert is a young woman, and the product is cosmetic, a product type commonly advertised to this target audience. The cosmetic in question is "Nivea Smooth Milk: Body", a type of moisturizing cream. As the ad is written in English and comes from a German (Western) company, it can be concluded that this advert comes from a Western cultural background. Since Nivea was founded in 1911, it can be inferred that this ad was made in 2011, due to the quote "100 years skin care for life". The ad seems to imply that physical attractiveness is the most important factor in a happy relationship, due to the happy couple featured in the image, and the slogan "For visibily smooth and touchably soft skin" (misspellings came with the ad), which seems to imply to the viewer that moisturizer brought the couple closer together (the image has the...
1 comment
Read more

Coriolanus and the Theme of Power

Shakespeare develops the theme of power in the play, mainly with the characters of Coriolanus, Volumnia, Aufidius, Menenius, and the Tribunes as representative of different forms of power. The titular character, Coriolanus, is a man from an older form of power, the absolute kind, where rulers did not have to answer to the commoners. He approaches politics the same way he approaches military matters: speaks his mind/heart (i.e. insulting the commoners, but it’s what he genuinely thinks of them), being true to himself, and insulting those he regards as enemies or against Rome (in battle this is the Volsces, but he believes that giving the plebeians a voice is a bad idea). In military, he is successful, because military power is absolute, obey or die type of deal, at least in that time; however, politics requires a surgical approach, and careful consideration of what to say, which the other characters mentioned can do better. Menenius acts as a foil to Coriolanus’ skills, because while h...
Post a Comment
Read more

Letter to the Editor - The Daily Mail

Dear Ms. Laura Clark, Your article, while raising a few interesting and worrying points, completely missed the mark. Instead of blasting ‘text speak’ and saying that “ Youngsters are also in danger of growing up with limited vocabularies because they spend so much of their free time on sites such as Twitter…”, perhaps you should look to the parents and authority figures who should be teaching the children about the English language before blaming technology. As a ‘youngster’ myself, I feel that you shift the blame on to text speak too much, and give it unfair credit. It is also rather insulting to observe the generation raising us, cast their responsibility on to inanimate devices, that they themselves gave us. The fact is, is that both teachers and parents share a certain responsibility to teach children to do the right thing. Perhaps the staff should have made a better effort in making sure that the children knew to differentiate their writing styles for different contexts and ...
1 comment
Read more